					
										 Share The Yum On Facebook									
																	
										Pin this recipe for later!									
																	
										Share The Yum On Facebook									
																	
										Pin this recipe for later!

There’s something about a sandwich cookie that feels like a small, private celebration—two thin discs of chocolate cupping a ribbon of peanut butter so the first bite is both familiar and a little indulgent. These Delish Chocolate Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies are exactly that kind of comfort: simple enough to make on a slow Sunday, special enough to bring out for a cozy afternoon when someone stops by with a paper bag of apples. The chocolate smell fills the kitchen, the peanut butter hums in the middle, and suddenly the ordinary day feels gilded.

At home, this is our little weekend ritual. I’ll admit my husband is the real enthusiast—he likes the ones with a little extra peanut butter, the sort where a finger print shows where he pressed the filling a beat too firmly. Our kiddo runs through the kitchen announcing everything (the dog waits loyally by the oven, his tail a metronome), and there’s always one half-drunk cup of coffee abandoned on the counter that I keep meaning to finish. Sometimes the filling oozes a smidge when a cookie is warm and the dog gives me the look, the one that says “I would help if allowed.” Honestly, the crumbs that collect on the counter are part of the charm—evidence of a relaxed afternoon and a family that’s allowed to be a little messy.

🍪

MORE OF OUR FAVORITE…

Why You’ll Love This Delish Chocolate Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies

– They’re comfort in two bites. The chocolate has a soft, deep warmth and the peanut butter center is rich and slightly salty, so each mouthful feels perfectly balanced.
– Texture play: a little snap when you bite, then a smooth, creamy melt. It’s the kind of contrast that makes you close your eyes for half a second and sigh—yes.
– They’re approachable. You don’t need a pastry degree to feel proud serving these. They’re ideal for a slow Sunday baking session or for putting a small, thoughtful pile on a neighbor’s doorstep.
– They travel well. Packed into a tin or a simple box, they’re a cozy, handheld treat for picnics, school lunches, or stashing for late-night snack raids.
– The aroma is homey and grounding—roasted cocoa and toasted peanut in the air, warm and softly sweet.

Slow Moments

There’s a particular kind of calm in making these that I treasure. It’s the pause while the oven hums and the kitchen fills with a quiet, toasty scent—time for one of those long, easy stretches of silence where the countertop becomes a stage for small gestures. I like to butter the tray slowly, tapping the bowl with a spoon and tasting a sliver of chocolate (don’t judge). My kid will inevitably appear mid-task, pressing a nose print onto a chocolate disk and declaring it the best cookie ever. My husband will be barefoot in the doorway, holding a mug and offering opinions on whether the peanut butter needs a pinch more salt. The dog will make an excellent, if persistent, sous-chef by offering moral support at ankle level.

I’ll stand there with my half-drunk coffee, stirring the last of it and letting the steam fog up my glasses if I’m not careful. The music is low—maybe something old with a piano—and there’s a measured rhythm to the making. For me, the joy isn’t in rushing to the end, but in those in-between moments: the way a ribbon of filling catches the light, the tiny rush of pride when the first tray comes out perfect, the second tray full of lopsided, charming misfits that somehow taste even better.

Time-Saving Hacks

– Use good-quality store-bought chocolate wafers or cookies when life is busy. The assembly still feels homemade and you save a lot of hands-on time.
– Make the filling ahead and keep it in a piping bag in the fridge. When the cookies are cool, a quick squeeze and you’re done—no fuss, just a neat sandwich.
– Freeze baked discs flat on a tray, then stack with parchment between layers in a container for an on-hand cookie stash. Pull them out to assemble as needed.
– Swap a portion of peanut butter for a slightly softer nut butter if you want a creamier center that spreads easily.
– Gentle reminder: a short pause to let the filling set actually leads to prettier sandwiches. Slowing down here rewards you with less drippy happiness.

Serving Ideas

– For a cozy afternoon, serve warm cookies with a small jug of milk or a steaming mug of coffee. The contrast of warm chocolate and cool milk is quietly nostalgic.
– For dessert, place a sandwich cookie beside a small scoop of vanilla or salted caramel ice cream—the textures sing together.
– For a simple weekend brunch, add a small platter of sliced apples, nuts, and perhaps a cheese that leans a bit aged to cut through the richness.
– Pack a few in a lunchbox with a note. They make a sweet, homey treat that feels like a hug in edible form.
– If you like sharing, a low, long board with a mix of cookies, fruit, and a big pot of tea makes for an unhurried, inviting spread.

Tips & Mistakes

I once overfilled a batch because I was distracted by a story my kid was telling about a very imaginary dragon—peanut butter everywhere, a sticky counter, an excited dog making off with a half-sandwich. Lesson learned: a little restraint goes a long way. Too much filling can turn a pretty cookie into a messy one, and warmth plus gravity is a relentless combination.

Another time I baked in a hurry and the cookies came out too soft, and they stuck to the tray when I tried to move them. My calm response was to sit and eat the slightly misshapen ones with a spoon. But the practical takeaway: give them a moment to firm up before you transfer. It saves both the cookies and a tiny bit of my patience.

Storage Tips

Store these in an airtight container at room temperature for a couple of days if you plan to eat them soon. If the weather is warm, pop them in the fridge so the filling stays set; they’re lovely chilled with a cup of coffee the next morning. For longer keeping, freeze assembled sandwiches separated with parchment. Thaw on the counter for a half hour before serving for softened centers and intact edges. I often tuck a few in my own lunch bag—a little reminder of home in the middle of the day.

Variations and Substitutions

I’ve tried almond butter for a gentler, nuttier center and it was quietly sophisticated—less punch, more hush. Dark chocolate with a touch of orange zest is a bright winter twist that I loved for its citrus lift. Using crunchy peanut butter adds a playful texture, though it can be a touch messier; the little peanut bits make the sandwiches delightfully rustic. One swap I didn’t love: too much flaky sea salt on top. It can be stunning in small doses, but go easy unless you want every bite to be a salty surprise. In autumn, I add a whisper of cinnamon to the filling—comfort in seasonal form.

Frequently Asked Questions

I can’t have gluten… will this still work?

Absolutely. Swap soy sauce for tamari or coconut aminos. It keeps the same comforting balance—I often do this for family dinners.

Do I have to peel the pineapple first?

Yes—the peel is too tough. Once it’s gone, the inside is tender and sweet, which is exactly what you want here.

Can I use canned pineapple instead of fresh?

You can. Drain it well; it’s not quite as bright as fresh, but it brings a gentle sweetness when you’re in a pinch.

How sweet is this? Can I tone it down?

Of course. Use a bit less sugar, or try honey or maple syrup. I often adjust depending on the season or time of day.

What if I skip the sesame oil?

That’s fine. You’ll miss a gentle toasty depth, but it remains a warm, comforting dish without it.

Remember it later

Planning to try this recipe soon? Pin it for a quick find later!